Garmin
Forerunner 165
$199.99
Withings
Based on 136 Reddit mentions
$289.00
Summary of sentiment across key features mentioned by users.
Discover what users really think based on Reddit discussions.
A friend of mine was going to get himself a Scanwatch from Withings. When I saw him again, he decided to get another brand. I asked why and he told me « I don’t want to have to pay a subscription for enjoying all the feature of a watch.» He did not understood, after seeing the subscription being pro
...Gillennial in r/withings
November 14, 2025 2:37 PM
11
I admire how much time you invest into diving deep here. Being a user of Withings watches and scales for almost ten years, I had my share of problems with the company. From buggy SW/Apps and device FW, through faulty HW, problems with the support (including lying to me and denying legally binding su
...pilsner1842 in r/withings
November 26, 2025 7:18 PM
8
Where does it say that? "During IFA 2025, Withings told us that all new features will be rolled out across the entire ScanWatch 2 range (ScanWatch 2, Nova, Brilliant, and Light). The only exception is the Light model, which does not include a temperature sensor and will therefore not support tempera
...DSMcGuire in r/withings
September 5, 2025 10:14 AM
14
I own an Apple Watch and a Withings ScanWatch 2, and since the update, I've honestly been wearing the Withings watch much more again. It used to just lie in the closet, and I would put it on from time to time because it's so pretty to look at. But for the past few days, I've been extremely happy wit
...Strandkorn12 in r/withings
October 16, 2025 3:47 PM
7
Pay them 600€ for this watch, and they still expect you to see withings+ ads everywhere in the app. And no ability to hide or turn them off. If you go to their website now, and put the scanwatch nova in the cart, the withings+ 100eur/year subscription is auto-selected and included in the purchase. A
...SonOfThomasWayne in r/withings
December 1, 2025 8:49 AM
7
Withings+ A brief recap: in 2022 we launched our subscription offer in the app, which initially provided access to nutritional and workout programs. Without any price increase, Withings+ has expanded since then to include new indicators like the long-term Health Improvement Score and the daily Vital
...TeamWithings in r/withings
November 17, 2025 7:57 PM
5
Works fine for me. Readings are relatively consistent between Withings Sleep Analyzer (or "Sleep" in the app?), ScanWatch Nova, and Oura Ring 4, although I mostly trust Oura on my sleep metrics. Heart rate, HRV, breathing rate, movement and sleep apnea readings are pretty consistent, but sleep phase
...Informal_Car3267 in r/withings
October 13, 2025 7:38 AM
4
I bought a Pininfarina Senso a while back. They look nice, and they pretty much do what they say they do. But they're not made well. The software and capabilities (of both the watch and the app) are clunky and limited compared to the Withings watches. Support was almost nonexistent. Mine broke (one
...mschley2 in r/withings
November 3, 2025 9:54 PM
4
I believe they moved it in the new version of the app and reset some of our already configured settings (which is pretty lame). Go to your devices (top right corner) > click on ScanWatch (if you have multiple devices) > Scroll down to Health features, click on "Respiratory Scan Not activated" > keep
...sainesk_btd6 in r/withings
November 13, 2025 8:34 PM
4
POTS is not a getting up problem, though. It's a staying up problem. You're focused on the wrong time period. You'd be much better off recording the test described here. I don't have an Apple watch, but you can probably record it as a workout on your watch to graph your HR tracking. Maybe someone el
...barefootwriter in r/POTS
July 9, 2025 7:24 PM
6